You are here

The Gardener's Cottage Scoops Reader Award for Best Local Restaurant in Scotland

A restaurant in Edinburgh has beaten eateries across Scotland to be named the Regional Winner for Scotland of the Waitrose Good Food Guide Reader's Restaurant of the Year Awards.

The Gardener's Cottage, on Royal Terrace Gardens between Leith Walk and Easter Road, has been nominated by its customers to be the top local restaurant in Scotland for the second time.

The establishment beat off stiff competition from some of Scotland's best-known restaurants.  The Gardener's Cottage is co-owned by chefs Dale Mailley and Edward Murray and sealed its win for its ‘inventive, locally sourced’ food'. 

The Good Food Guide, published by Waitrose, called for diners, back in March, to nominate their favourite local eatery.  The coveted awards honour the very best independent restaurants, pubs and cafés from around the country.  The annual awards recognise the top dining establishments across ten different UK regions and are based on public nominations with a panel of Good Food Guide judges choosing the most outstanding for their overall winner, which this year is The Miller of Mansfield in Goring, Oxfordshire.  

Elizabeth Carter, Waitrose Good Food Guide Editor, says: "This award is a celebration of small, independent restaurants that specialise in amazing quality food, often at great value prices.

“While trained inspectors carry out all our reviews, we rely on readers to let us know about eateries that might otherwise be overlooked. They are incredibly sophisticated when it comes to eating out, so it makes sense to listen to their opinions.

"At The Gardener's Cottage the battered blackboard menu in the garden gives notice of a different kind of venue to the big-city norm. For many readers it is ‘just an amazing place’.

“The tiny restaurant, which really was a gardener’s cottage, with its two communal tables, makes a congenial setting for inventive, locally-sourced food, which comes in simple but powerfully appealing guises."

Edward Murray, co-owner of The Gardener's Cottage, said "We are thrilled to have won the Good Food Guide readers’ award for Scotland. 

“It is an honour to be recognised by the guide and wonderful to know that our customers enjoy our food and service as much as we enjoy providing it."

The Gardener's Cottage was previously the 2014 Waitrose Good Food Guide's 'Reader's Restaurant of the Year - Regional Winner for Scotland'. 

The regional winners and overall winner have been announced today (30th July 2015).  Now in its ninth year, the award attracted 18,000 nominations after calling on diners to name their favourite local eatery in March 2015. 

The regional winners are as follows:


Scotland, The Gardener’s Cottage (Edinburgh)
South East and Overall Winner, The Miller of Mansfield (Goring, Oxfordshire)
London, Boqueria Tapas  (Brixton, London)
North East, Lockwoods (Ripon, Yorkshire)
Northern Ireland, James Street South (Belfast)
North West, Lunya (Liverpool)
Wales, The Gallery (Barry)
Midlands, The King and Thai (Broseley)
South West, Ben's Cornish Kitchen (Marazion, Cornwall)
East England, The Leaping Hare (Stanton, Suffolk)